A Cybil Discussion

Recently comments about The Cybils have been bouncing about the kidlitosphere. Comments have ranged from "whew! Am I tired from reading 80 some books" to "what the heck are they thinking?" (All quotes approximate.) Well, we want to know what you're thinking. Today we want to know what you think about the shortlists. Even about the idea of shortlists. Head on over and discuss. We want to hear from you.